DGCity
— A Window to China

Nanjing's Zero-Yuan Noodle Shops Draw Queues and Complaints

Every lunchtime, long queues form outside two modest storefronts in Nanjing where the menu has a single item and the price is zero: a bowl of vegetarian noodle soup. The city’s so-called zero-yuan noodle shops have fed thousands of people a day since opening last month, but their sudden popularity has split the neighborhood and forced regulators to weigh private charity against the livelihoods of nearby businesses.

The two shops, one in the Yinxiang area of Jiangning district and another in the Daishan area of Yuhuatai district, were opened in October by a local businessman surnamed Zhang, who said he wanted to offer people in difficulty a hot meal with dignity. Diners must bring their own bowls, queue in order and cannot take food away. Over a short lunch window and again at dinner, staff hand out roughly six bowls a minute, each topped with bean-curd chicken, shiitake mushrooms and mixed vegetables. The crowds lean heavily on day laborers from nearby labor-dispatch agencies, elderly residents, sanitation workers, food-delivery riders and people with disabilities. Zhang estimates the two shops will cost him about 10 million yuan a year.

The friction comes from the fact that the queues also include plenty of people who can afford to pay. Noodle sellers within a few hundred meters have felt the difference most sharply: one Anhui-style board-noodle shop around a hundred meters away said it lost roughly two dozen customers and a few hundred yuan each day, and its owner plans to leave when the lease expires next spring. Another nearby shop reported daily takings dropping by about 2,000 yuan within a week. Eateries with different menus, dinner-hour business or a stable base of regulars mostly reported little impact.

Market regulators in Jiangning inspected the shop, confirmed that its licenses were complete and ordered ingredient tests, which came back clean. They said giving food away for charitable reasons is not against the law, and that on the evidence gathered so far the shop does not amount to unfair competition, although a multi-agency review is still underway. Zhang, who said he surveyed the surrounding streets before signing the lease, has offered to compensate any eatery within 200 meters that can prove losses; the day after opening, he personally handed 10,000 yuan to one neighboring noodle shop.

Charity scholars are cautious. A Tsinghua University public administration professor called the shops an unusual form of giving that does not fit the categories of the Charity Law: aid offered to everyone, including people who can pay, inevitably spills into the marketplace, whereas food banks in other countries narrowly target the needy and keep costs low. A researcher at the Jiangsu provincial academy of social sciences said the goodwill deserves respect but will eventually have to reckon with sustainability.

For now the queues keep forming, and the question hovering over the steaming pots in both neighborhoods is a practical one: whether kindness offered without conditions can coexist with small shop owners who still need customers of their own to pay the rent.

Like(0)
未经允许不得转载:Dgcity » Nanjing's Zero-Yuan Noodle Shops Draw Queues and Complaints

Sign In

Forgot Password

Sign Up